I had a feeling Melanie Amaro would win XFactor USA. Not because she was amazing or unique but because of the big deal that was made of bringing her back. Simon Cowell was so torn about the “mistake” he made not putting her through at the start that he was magically allowed one more singer on his team than everyone else.
Melanie never stood out. Not like Torah who didn’t make ut go the live shows, or Rachel Crow and Drew. She was and is a run of the mill Mariah Carey-alike.
I certainly won’t be buying her album. I will buy Chris Rene’s.
Next time producers, make it less obvious which plain girl with a sob story you are going to makeover and make into a cookie cutter star.